2025 · how every team was managed

Front office

Draft, moves and lineup calls, graded against the league.

GM report card

Who's running their team best

#Team GM Draft Moves Lineups AddsDropsTradesMissed starts Bench pts leftGames costBest moveWorst move
1 |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem7–7 · 8 adds · 7 drops A+ A+ B++140 B-16.6/wk 87—27 233 — Kimani Vidal (waiver added, A+) Cam Little (dropped, F)
2 Monday Nightshift5–9 · 8 adds · 8 drops A A B-+61 B+15.1/wk 88—27 212 3 Theo Johnson (waiver added, A+) Jake Bates (dropped, F)
3 The Beefalo's8–5–1 · 13 adds · 13 drops A- B+ A-+152 B-18.3/wk 1313—32 256 1 Daniel Jones (fa added, A-) Matt Prater (dropped, F)
4 McPini Championship Co5–9 · 8 adds · 7 drops B+ B A++342 C19.6/wk 87—28 274 4 Matthew Stafford (fa added, A+) Bills D/ST (dropped, F)
5 Keystone St. Of Mind7–7 · 14 adds · 14 drops B C A+190 B16.2/wk 1414—26 227 1 Jacoby Brissett (fa added, A+) Troy Franklin (dropped, F)
6 Mr McGibblets9–5 · 17 adds · 17 drops · 1 trade B- A- B+137 F22.3/wk 1717132 312 3 Lions D/ST (fa added, A+) Colston Loveland (dropped, F)
7 Lawrenceville United6–7–1 · 17 adds · 16 drops B- B- F-129 A-14.8/wk 1716—27 207 2 Sam Darnold (fa added, A+) Trevor Lawrence (dropped, F)
8 Jack Reachers6–8 · 15 adds · 15 drops · 1 trade C+ F C++48 A+10.1/wk 1515124 142 1 Jason Myers (fa added, A+) Lions D/ST (dropped, F)
9 Brick Squad5–8–1 · 10 adds · 10 drops · 1 trade C B- F-139 A13.4/wk 1010126 188 5 Dallas Goedert (fa added, A+) Jaxson Dart (dropped, F)
10 Suck My Ditka8–5–1 · 9 adds · 9 drops · 2 trades D C+ B-+73 F21.4/wk 99230 300 2 Jake Bates (fa added, A+) Eagles D/ST (dropped, F)
11 Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA9–5 · 36 adds · 36 drops F F C-19 C+19.4/wk 3636—35 272 2 Michael Wilson (fa added, A+) Woody Marks (dropped, F)
12 crEam7–7 · 20 adds · 18 drops · 1 trade F D D-42 D20.0/wk 2018132 280 4 Bills D/ST (fa added, A+) Will Reichard (dropped, F)

Draft = points drafted players scored for the team vs. picks made near the same slot. Moves = points pickups scored as your starters, minus points your drops scored as someone else's starters, plus trade value since the deal. Lineups = points left on the bench each week (a bench player who outscored the weakest starter he could have replaced). Each is curved best-to-worst; GM is the average.

🪑 Bench watch

Benchings that cost a game

  1. +27Mr McGibblets sat Wan'Dale Robinson (WR, 28) for Courtland Sutton (1)Week 2 · lost 102–107 to |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem
  2. +27Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA sat Jaxson Dart (QB, 30) for Justin Fields (3)Week 7 · lost 100–139 to Lawrenceville United
  3. +26McPini Championship Co sat Rome Odunze (WR, 31) for Travis Hunter (5)Week 2 · lost 115–118 to Lawrenceville United
  4. +26Mr McGibblets sat Wan'Dale Robinson (WR, 30) for Stefon Diggs (4)Week 12 · lost 85–103 to McPini Championship Co
  5. +24Mr McGibblets sat Courtland Sutton (WR, 26) for Tee Higgins (2)Week 3 · lost 71–104 to Lawrenceville United
  6. +24crEam sat Justice Hill (RB, 31) for Jakobi Meyers (7)Week 4 · lost 105–115 to Keystone St. Of Mind
  7. +24McPini Championship Co sat Travis Hunter (WR, 24) for Jameson Williams (0)Week 7 · lost 105–139 to Suck My Ditka
  8. +24crEam sat Tetairoa McMillan (WR, 33) for Rashee Rice (9)Week 11 · lost 100–112 to Mr McGibblets
  9. +22Mr McGibblets sat Javonte Williams (RB, 24) for Derrick Henry (2)Week 2 · lost 102–107 to |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem
  10. +22Monday Nightshift sat D'Andre Swift (RB, 27) for Deebo Samuel (5)Week 6 · lost 132–134 to Lawrenceville United
  11. +22McPini Championship Co sat Sam LaPorta (TE, 22) for Alvin Kamara (0)Week 9 · lost 98–104 to The Beefalo's
  12. +21crEam sat Justin Herbert (QB, 27) for Bo Nix (6)Week 1 · lost 92–100 to Jack Reachers

Biggest misses

Worst benchings

  1. +36Suck My Ditka · DeVonta Smith 36 on the bench, Mike Evans 0 startedWeek 7 · result 139–105
  2. +30The Beefalo's · Tony Pollard 31 on the bench, DJ Moore 1 startedWeek 14 · result 95–73
  3. +27Mr McGibblets · Wan'Dale Robinson 28 on the bench, Courtland Sutton 1 startedWeek 2 · lost 102–107
  4. +27Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA · Jaxson Dart 30 on the bench, Justin Fields 3 startedWeek 7 · lost 100–139
  5. +26McPini Championship Co · Rome Odunze 31 on the bench, Travis Hunter 5 startedWeek 2 · lost 115–118
  6. +26Mr McGibblets · Wan'Dale Robinson 30 on the bench, Stefon Diggs 4 startedWeek 12 · lost 85–103
  7. +26|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem · Hunter Henry 29 on the bench, Zay Flowers 3 startedWeek 3 · result 134–76
  8. +24Mr McGibblets · Courtland Sutton 26 on the bench, Tee Higgins 2 startedWeek 3 · lost 71–104
  9. +24crEam · Justice Hill 31 on the bench, Jakobi Meyers 7 startedWeek 4 · lost 105–115
  10. +24McPini Championship Co · Travis Hunter 24 on the bench, Jameson Williams 0 startedWeek 7 · lost 105–139
  11. +24crEam · Tetairoa McMillan 33 on the bench, Rashee Rice 9 startedWeek 11 · lost 100–112
  12. +24Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA · Harold Fannin Jr. 25 on the bench, Oronde Gadsden II 1 startedWeek 14 · result 96–85
  13. +24Lawrenceville United · Jacory Croskey-Merritt 26 on the bench, Woody Marks 2 startedWeek 5 · result 139–127
  14. +23Lawrenceville United · Sam Darnold 21 on the bench, Tyrod Taylor -2 startedWeek 14 · result 94–133
  15. +23|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem · Jameis Winston 31 on the bench, Josh Allen 8 startedWeek 12 · result 154–109

345 moves

Every pickup & drop, graded

GradeMoveTeamImpactWhen
B Dropped Emari Demercado RBThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's 0 2025-12-28
B Fa Added Giants D/ST DSTThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's +20.0 2025-12-28
B Dropped David Njoku TEThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's 0 2025-12-17
C Fa Added Colby Parkinson TEThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's +4.0 2025-12-17
B Fa Added Bengals D/ST DSTBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA +14.0 2025-12-17
B Dropped Tua Tagovailoa QBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-12-17
B Waiver Added Eddy Pineiro KMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets +18.0 2025-12-17
C Waiver Added Michael Carter RBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA +6.0 2025-12-17
B Dropped Isaac TeSlaa WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-12-17
B Dropped Chargers D/ST DSTMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets 0 2025-12-17
A- Waiver Added Saints D/ST DSTMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets +34.0 2025-12-17
B Dropped Evan McPherson KMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets 0 2025-12-17
B Dropped Bo Nix QBcrEam crEam 0 2025-12-14
C Fa Added Shedeur Sanders QBcrEam crEam +3.0 2025-12-14
B Dropped Daniel Jones QBThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's 0 2025-12-09
B Fa Added Eagles D/ST DSTLawrenceville United Lawrenceville United +22.0 2025-12-07
A- Fa Added AJ Barner TEMonday Nightshift Monday Nightshift +37.0 2025-12-06
C Fa Added John Metchie III WRcrEam crEam +7.0 2025-12-06
B Dropped Justice Hill RBcrEam crEam 0 2025-12-06
A- Fa Added Harrison Mevis K|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem +41.0 2025-12-04
B Dropped Andy Borregales K|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem 0 2025-12-04
B Dropped Darius Slayton WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-12-04
C Fa Added Tua Tagovailoa QBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA +9.0 2025-12-04
B Dropped Packers D/ST DSTThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's 0 2025-12-03
C Fa Added Commanders D/ST DSTThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's +4.0 2025-12-03
B Dropped Tez Johnson WRSuck My Ditka Suck My Ditka 0 2025-12-03
B Fa Added Brenton Strange TESuck My Ditka Suck My Ditka +13.0 2025-12-03
B Dropped Cade Otton TESuck My Ditka Suck My Ditka 0 2025-12-03
C Dropped John Metchie III WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA -14.0 2025-12-03
D Fa Added Isaac TeSlaa WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-12-03
D Fa Added Tyrod Taylor QBLawrenceville United Lawrenceville United -2.0 2025-12-03
B Dropped Brashard Smith RBLawrenceville United Lawrenceville United 0 2025-12-03
B Waiver Added Trevor Lawrence QBMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets +18.0 2025-12-03
B Dropped Ravens D/ST DSTBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-12-03
B Waiver Added Adonai Mitchell WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA +15.0 2025-12-03
B Dropped J.J. McCarthy QBMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets 0 2025-12-03
B Dropped Raiders D/ST DSTLawrenceville United Lawrenceville United 0 2025-12-02
B Dropped Nick Chubb RBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-11-30
B Dropped Nick Folk KKeystone St. Of Mind Keystone St. Of Mind 0 2025-11-27
A- Fa Added Zane Gonzalez KKeystone St. Of Mind Keystone St. Of Mind +47.0 2025-11-27
A- Fa Added 49ers D/ST DSTThe Beefalo's The Beefalo's +27.0 2025-11-27
B Dropped Matthew Golden WRJack Reachers Jack Reachers 0 2025-11-27
B Dropped Terrell Jennings RBKeystone St. Of Mind Keystone St. Of Mind 0 2025-11-27
F Dropped Trevor Lawrence QBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA -116.0 2025-11-26
D Fa Added John Metchie III WRBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA 0 2025-11-26
B Dropped Chad Ryland KMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets 0 2025-11-26
A- Waiver Added Chargers D/ST DSTMr McGibblets Mr McGibblets +40.0 2025-11-26
B Dropped Michael Badgley K|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem 0 2025-11-23
C Fa Added Chris Brooks RB|\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem +3.0 2025-11-23
B Fa Added Trevor Lawrence QBBobby Schwags BALSAGNA Bobby Schwags BALSAGNA +16.0 2025-11-21

⬇ Download these moves (CSV) · A+ = elite move (big production for you / you dropped nothing of value) … F = the move hurt you.

Trades

Who won the deal

  • 2025-10-15 · early read
    DSuck My DitkaRashee Rice, Ashton Jeanty, Tyler Warren-14
    BcrEamChristian McCaffrey, Dalton Kincaid, Jakobi Meyers, Michael Mayer+2
  • 2025-10-01
    DBrick SquadMarvin Harrison Jr.-11
    BCute BALSAGNARJ Harvey+6
  • 2025-09-17 · early read
    A+Mr McGibbletsDeVonta Smith, Omarion Hampton+62
    FSuck My DitkaDavid Montgomery, Christian Kirk-41
  • 2025-09-17 · early read
    A+Cute BALSAGNAChris Olave+93
    FJack ReachersNick Chubb-8

NFL scores & field