2014 draft · graded on what picks scored for the team that drafted them

Draft grades

Each pick is compared with players taken within 12 slots of it; teams are curved best to worst. See the graded board →

Sorted by points above slot expectation

Team report

#TeamGradevs slotHit rateBest pickBiggest bustPts from picksBiggest miss
1 Lawrenceville United18 picks A+ +503 61% Antonio Brown (rd 2, +158.5) Ray Rice (rd 5, -52.9) 1216 Ray Rice over Andrew Luck (−264)
2 Monday Nightshift18 picks A +396 61% Jay Cutler (rd 17, +138.2) Bishop Sankey (rd 5, -39.7) 1133 Bishop Sankey over Andrew Luck (−252)
3 The Beefalo's18 picks A- +381 56% Antonio Gates (rd 13, +110.8) Brandon Marshall (rd 2, -18) 1115 Eric Ebron over Le'Veon Bell (−218)
4 Brick Squad18 picks B+ +307 72% Jordy Nelson (rd 2, +147.2) Doug Martin (rd 3, -58.6) 1028 Joique Bell over Andrew Luck (−212)
5 Keystone St. Of Mind18 picks B +131 56% Le'Veon Bell (rd 10, +181.4) Markus Wheaton (rd 3, -83.2) 849 Ladarius Green over Andrew Luck (−264)
6 Jack Reachers18 picks B- +52 33% Andrew Luck (rd 6, +216.9) A.J. Green (rd 2, -52.7) 782 Chris Johnson over Andrew Luck (−235)
7 McPini Championship Co18 picks B- +46 50% Matt Forte (rd 1, +126.1) Montee Ball (rd 2, -69.4) 767 Ryan Mathews over Andrew Luck (−264)
8 Suck My Ditka18 picks C+ -61 50% Martellus Bennett (rd 8, +94.7) Demaryius Thomas (rd 1, -88.6) 672 Demaryius Thomas over Antonio Brown (−226)
9 crEam18 picks C -118 56% DeMarco Murray (rd 2, +116) Pierre Garcon (rd 4, -38.1) 594 Pierre Garcon over Andrew Luck (−258)
10 Cute BALSAGNA18 picks D -216 28% Dez Bryant (rd 2, +103.1) Peyton Manning (rd 1, -47) 507 Toby Gerhart over Andrew Luck (−247)
11 |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem18 picks F -688 11% Andrew Hawkins (rd 15, -12.4) Eddie Lacy (rd 1, -116.5) 0 Vincent Jackson over Andrew Luck (−264)
12 Mr McGibblets18 picks F -693 6% Cardinals D/ST (rd 15, -11.6) Calvin Johnson (rd 1, -118.5) 0 Wes Welker over Andrew Luck (−264)

Most points above their slot

💎 Steals

  1. A+Andrew Luck QB · pick 61 (rd 6) · Jack Reachers264 pts for them · +216.9 vs slot
  2. A+Le'Veon Bell RB · pick 118 (rd 10) · Keystone St. Of Mind218 pts for them · +181.4 vs slot
  3. A+Antonio Brown WR · pick 19 (rd 2) · Lawrenceville United260 pts for them · +158.5 vs slot
  4. A+Randall Cobb WR · pick 123 (rd 11) · Keystone St. Of Mind198 pts for them · +154.5 vs slot
  5. A+Jordy Nelson WR · pick 24 (rd 2) · Brick Squad240 pts for them · +147.2 vs slot
  6. A+Jay Cutler QB · pick 194 (rd 17) · Monday Nightshift159 pts for them · +138.2 vs slot
  7. A+Kelvin Benjamin WR · pick 115 (rd 10) · Lawrenceville United170 pts for them · +132.5 vs slot
  8. A+Matt Forte RB · pick 4 (rd 1) · McPini Championship Co252 pts for them · +126.1 vs slot
  9. A+DeMarco Murray RB · pick 16 (rd 2) · crEam227 pts for them · +116 vs slot
  10. A+Antonio Gates TE · pick 155 (rd 13) · The Beefalo's125 pts for them · +110.8 vs slot

Rounds 1–5, furthest below their slot

💀 Busts

  1. FCalvin Johnson WR · pick 5 (rd 1) · Mr McGibblets0 pts for them · -118.5 vs slot · passed on Antonio Brown
  2. FEddie Lacy RB · pick 8 (rd 1) · |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem0 pts for them · -116.5 vs slot · passed on Antonio Brown
  3. FDrew Brees QB · pick 17 (rd 2) · |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem0 pts for them · -100.9 vs slot · passed on Antonio Brown
  4. FAaron Rodgers QB · pick 20 (rd 2) · Mr McGibblets0 pts for them · -100.2 vs slot · passed on Jordy Nelson
  5. FDemaryius Thomas WR · pick 7 (rd 1) · Suck My Ditka34 pts for them · -88.6 vs slot · passed on Antonio Brown
  6. FMarkus Wheaton WR · pick 27 (rd 3) · Keystone St. Of Mind0 pts for them · -83.2 vs slot · passed on Andre Ellington
  7. FMontee Ball RB · pick 21 (rd 2) · McPini Championship Co32 pts for them · -69.4 vs slot · passed on Jordy Nelson
  8. FAlfred Morris RB · pick 29 (rd 3) · Mr McGibblets0 pts for them · -65.9 vs slot · passed on Andre Ellington
  9. FZac Stacy RB · pick 32 (rd 3) · |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem0 pts for them · -59.6 vs slot · passed on Roddy White
  10. FDoug Martin RB · pick 25 (rd 3) · Brick Squad28 pts for them · -58.6 vs slot · passed on Arian Foster

Round 10 or later

🔍 Late-round gems

  1. A+Le'Veon Bell RB · pick 118 (rd 10) · Keystone St. Of Mind218 pts for them · +181.4 vs slot
  2. A+Randall Cobb WR · pick 123 (rd 11) · Keystone St. Of Mind198 pts for them · +154.5 vs slot
  3. A+Kelvin Benjamin WR · pick 115 (rd 10) · Lawrenceville United170 pts for them · +132.5 vs slot
  4. A+Jay Cutler QB · pick 194 (rd 17) · Monday Nightshift159 pts for them · +138.2 vs slot
  5. A+Antonio Gates TE · pick 155 (rd 13) · The Beefalo's125 pts for them · +110.8 vs slot
  6. ADelanie Walker TE · pick 191 (rd 16) · Monday Nightshift106 pts for them · +81.4 vs slot

Every draft since 2009

All-time drafting

#FranchiseAvg gradeDraftsTotal vs slotBest draftWorst draft
1Monday NightshiftA-18+41152020 A+2019 D
2Brick SquadB+18+33502026 A+2017 C
3Lawrenceville UnitedB+18+33072014 A+2022 C
4McPini Championship CoB18+30112021 A+2019 F
5The Beefalo'sB18+21582018 A2023 D
6Jack ReachersB18+18402022 A+2024 F
7Team I Like SandwichB-1+612009 B-2009 B-
8Keystone St. Of MindB-18+6242016 A+2021 F
9Suck My DitkaC+18+4432024 A+2026 F
10|\/|cNAlR'S MayhemC+17-53512025 A+2016 F
11Cute BALSAGNAC18-17662013 A2025 F
12Blue Lagoon's Blue BaracudasC1-1442009 C2009 C
13FRESH MEATC5-19132020 B-2018 F
14Mr McGibbletsC12-52242024 A2014 F
15crEamD18-43112011 B-2023 F

NFL scores & field