2023 draft · graded on what picks scored for the team that drafted them
Draft grades
Each pick is compared with players taken within 12 slots of it; teams are curved best to worst. See the graded board →
Sorted by points above slot expectation
Team report
| # | Team | Grade | vs slot | Pts from picks | Biggest miss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem17 picks | A+ | +601 | 2334 | David Njoku over Dak Prescott (−186) |
| 2 | Lawrenceville United17 picks | A | +340 | 2079 | Aaron Rodgers over Dak Prescott (−267) |
| 3 | Monday Nightshift17 picks | A- | +338 | 2092 | Juwan Johnson over Raheem Mostert (−218) |
| 4 | Keystone St. Of Mind17 picks | B+ | +93 | 1829 | Rashaad Penny over Tua Tagovailoa (−226) |
| 5 | Brick Squad17 picks | B | +92 | 1847 | Adam Thielen over Tua Tagovailoa (−224) |
| 6 | McPini Championship Co17 picks | B- | +20 | 1751 | JuJu Smith-Schuster over Dak Prescott (−253) |
| 7 | Suck My Ditka17 picks | B- | -14 | 1704 | Jaylen Waddle over Josh Allen (−278) |
| 8 | Jack Reachers17 picks | C+ | -139 | 1598 | Clyde Edwards-Helaire over Raheem Mostert (−206) |
| 9 | Mr McGibblets17 picks | C | -190 | 1514 | Marvin Mims Jr. over Dak Prescott (−265) |
| 10 | The Beefalo's17 picks | D | -212 | 1503 | Nick Chubb over Josh Allen (−279) |
| 11 | Cute BALSAGNA17 picks | F | -294 | 1421 | Elijah Mitchell over Dak Prescott (−259) |
| 12 | crEam17 picks | F | -710 | 1002 | Nelson Agholor over Dak Prescott (−267) |
Most points above their slot
💎 Steals
- A+Dak Prescott QB · pick 140 (rd 12) · McPini Championship Co267 pts for them · +171.6 vs slot
- A+Tyreek Hill WR · pick 6 (rd 1) · |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem336 pts for them · +171.1 vs slot
- A+Raheem Mostert RB · pick 161 (rd 14) · Keystone St. Of Mind227 pts for them · +164.2 vs slot
- A+Josh Allen QB · pick 29 (rd 3) · McPini Championship Co301 pts for them · +139.4 vs slot
- A+Keenan Allen WR · pick 38 (rd 4) · Mr McGibblets276 pts for them · +131 vs slot
- A+Michael Pittman Jr. WR · pick 93 (rd 8) · Lawrenceville United218 pts for them · +128.4 vs slot
- A+Jalen Hurts QB · pick 30 (rd 3) · |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem286 pts for them · +126.8 vs slot
- A+Tua Tagovailoa QB · pick 128 (rd 11) · Keystone St. Of Mind227 pts for them · +125.1 vs slot
- A+Matthew Stafford QB · pick 180 (rd 15) · The Beefalo's185 pts for them · +124.9 vs slot
- A+CeeDee Lamb WR · pick 15 (rd 2) · Jack Reachers275 pts for them · +116.4 vs slot
Rounds 1–5, furthest below their slot
💀 Busts
- FJaylen Waddle WR · pick 22 (rd 2) · Suck My Ditka23 pts for them · -139.6 vs slot · passed on Josh Allen
- FNick Chubb RB · pick 12 (rd 1) · The Beefalo's22 pts for them · -137.6 vs slot · passed on Josh Allen
- FJoe Mixon RB · pick 27 (rd 3) · Suck My Ditka34 pts for them · -131.7 vs slot · passed on Josh Allen
- FDameon Pierce RB · pick 39 (rd 4) · Jack Reachers50 pts for them · -96.4 vs slot · passed on Lamar Jackson
- FRachaad White RB · pick 48 (rd 4) · Cute BALSAGNA49 pts for them · -96.1 vs slot · passed on Lamar Jackson
- FGeorge Kittle TE · pick 47 (rd 4) · crEam54 pts for them · -91.7 vs slot · passed on Lamar Jackson
- FChris Olave WR · pick 20 (rd 2) · McPini Championship Co77 pts for them · -83 vs slot · passed on Josh Allen
- FChristian McCaffrey RB · pick 2 (rd 1) · crEam71 pts for them · -76.3 vs slot · passed on Tyreek Hill
- FAaron Jones RB · pick 36 (rd 3) · The Beefalo's70 pts for them · -76 vs slot · passed on Keenan Allen
- FJosh Jacobs RB · pick 11 (rd 1) · Mr McGibblets88 pts for them · -74.5 vs slot · passed on Josh Allen
Round 10 or later
🔍 Late-round gems
- A+Dak Prescott QB · pick 140 (rd 12) · McPini Championship Co267 pts for them · +171.6 vs slot
- A+Tua Tagovailoa QB · pick 128 (rd 11) · Keystone St. Of Mind227 pts for them · +125.1 vs slot
- A+Raheem Mostert RB · pick 161 (rd 14) · Keystone St. Of Mind227 pts for them · +164.2 vs slot
- ARussell Wilson QB · pick 130 (rd 11) · Jack Reachers213 pts for them · +110.6 vs slot
- AJared Goff QB · pick 129 (rd 11) · Monday Nightshift207 pts for them · +100.9 vs slot
- A+Nico Collins WR · pick 117 (rd 10) · Lawrenceville United195 pts for them · +114.5 vs slot
Every draft since 2009
All-time drafting
| # | Franchise | Avg grade | Drafts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Monday Nightshift | A- | 18 |
| 2 | Brick Squad | B+ | 18 |
| 3 | Lawrenceville United | B+ | 18 |
| 4 | McPini Championship Co | B | 18 |
| 5 | The Beefalo's | B | 18 |
| 6 | Jack Reachers | B | 18 |
| 7 | Team I Like Sandwich | B- | 1 |
| 8 | Keystone St. Of Mind | B- | 18 |
| 9 | Suck My Ditka | C+ | 18 |
| 10 | |\/|cNAlR'S Mayhem | C+ | 17 |
| 11 | Cute BALSAGNA | C | 18 |
| 12 | Blue Lagoon's Blue Baracudas | C | 1 |
| 13 | FRESH MEAT | C | 5 |
| 14 | Mr McGibblets | C | 12 |
| 15 | crEam | D | 18 |